The S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 are two iconic revolvers that have been in competition with each other for decades. Both revolvers have a rich history and a loyal following, making the rivalry between them even more intense. In this article, we will compare and contrast the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 in terms of design, accuracy, trigger and action, recoil and handling, capacity and reloading, durability and maintenance, as well as price and value. By the end of this article, you will have a clear understanding of which revolver reigns supreme in the S&W 686 vs. Ruger GP100 rivalry.
Design and Build: Comparing the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100
The S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 both feature a classic revolver design with a double-action/single-action mechanism. The S&W 686 has a sleek and streamlined appearance with a stainless steel frame and barrel. It has a full underlug barrel design that adds weight to the front end of the revolver, reducing muzzle rise and improving stability during rapid fire. On the other hand, the Ruger GP100 has a more robust and rugged design with a stainless steel frame that is known for its durability.
In terms of build quality, both revolvers are known for their exceptional craftsmanship. The S&W 686 is renowned for its smooth action and tight lockup, while the Ruger GP100 is praised for its robust construction that can withstand heavy use. Both revolvers are built to last and can handle thousands of rounds without any issues.
Accuracy and Precision: Which Revolver Comes Out on Top?
When it comes to accuracy and precision, both the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 are top contenders. The S&W 686 is known for its excellent accuracy due to its tight tolerances and superior barrel design. It has a longer sight radius compared to the Ruger GP100, which contributes to its accuracy. The Ruger GP100, on the other hand, is also highly accurate and is known for its consistent point of impact. It has a shorter sight radius compared to the S&W 686, but it compensates for it with its excellent build quality and barrel design.
In terms of sights, both revolvers offer a variety of options. The S&W 686 typically comes with adjustable rear sights and a red ramp front sight, allowing for precise aiming. The Ruger GP100 also offers adjustable rear sights and a variety of front sight options, including fiber optic and tritium night sights. Overall, both revolvers offer excellent accuracy and precision, making them suitable for target shooting and self-defense purposes.
Trigger and Action: Evaluating the Performance of Both Revolvers
The trigger and action of a revolver play a crucial role in its performance. The S&W 686 features a smooth double-action trigger pull and a crisp single-action trigger pull. The double-action trigger pull is known for its smoothness and consistency, allowing for accurate shots even in rapid-fire situations. The single-action trigger pull is light and crisp, making it ideal for precise shots.
The Ruger GP100 also has a smooth double-action trigger pull and a crisp single-action trigger pull. However, some users have reported that the double-action trigger pull on the Ruger GP100 can be slightly heavier compared to the S&W 686. Nonetheless, both revolvers offer excellent trigger performance that is suitable for both novice and experienced shooters.
Recoil and Handling: How Do These Revolvers Feel in Your Hands?
Recoil and handling are important factors to consider when choosing a revolver. The S&W 686 has a slightly heavier frame compared to the Ruger GP100, which helps to mitigate recoil. It also has ergonomic grips that provide a comfortable and secure hold, reducing felt recoil even further. The S&W 686 is known for its excellent balance and handling, making it a pleasure to shoot.
The Ruger GP100, on the other hand, has a slightly lighter frame compared to the S&W 686. This can result in slightly more felt recoil, especially when shooting heavier loads. However, the Ruger GP100 also has ergonomic grips that provide a comfortable and secure hold, minimizing the impact of recoil. Overall, both revolvers offer excellent recoil management and handling, allowing for accurate and controlled shooting.
Capacity and Reloading: Which Revolver Offers More Convenience?
Capacity and reloading are important considerations for those who plan to use their revolver for self-defense purposes. The S&W 686 typically comes with a 6-round cylinder capacity, although there are models available with a 7-round capacity. Reloading the S&W 686 is relatively straightforward, requiring the user to swing out the cylinder and manually eject spent casings before loading fresh rounds.
The Ruger GP100 also has a 6-round cylinder capacity, although there are models available with a 7-round capacity as well. Reloading the Ruger GP100 is similar to the S&W 686, requiring the user to swing out the cylinder and manually eject spent casings before loading fresh rounds. Both revolvers offer convenient reloading options and have ample capacity for self-defense purposes.
Durability and Maintenance: Which Revolver Requires Less Upkeep?
Durability and maintenance are important factors to consider when choosing a revolver. The S&W 686 is known for its exceptional durability, thanks to its stainless steel construction and robust design. It can handle thousands of rounds without any issues and is resistant to corrosion and wear. In terms of maintenance, the S&W 686 requires regular cleaning and lubrication to ensure smooth operation.
The Ruger GP100 is also highly durable, thanks to its stainless steel construction and rugged design. It is built to withstand heavy use and can handle thousands of rounds without any issues. In terms of maintenance, the Ruger GP100 requires regular cleaning and lubrication, similar to the S&W 686. Both revolvers are built to last and require minimal upkeep.
Price and Value: Assessing the Cost of the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100
When it comes to price and value, the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 offer excellent options at different price points. The S&W 686 is typically priced higher compared to the Ruger GP100, reflecting its superior craftsmanship and reputation. However, the Ruger GP100 offers excellent value for its price, providing a reliable and durable revolver at a more affordable cost.
User Reviews: What Do Owners Say About These Revolvers?
User reviews for both the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 are overwhelmingly positive. Owners of the S&W 686 praise its accuracy, smooth action, and overall build quality. They appreciate its reliability and durability, making it a popular choice among shooters.
Owners of the Ruger GP100 also have high praise for its accuracy, durability, and overall performance. They appreciate its robust construction and reliability, making it a favorite among those who put their revolvers through heavy use.
Which Revolver Reigns Supreme in the S&W 686 vs. Ruger GP100 Rivalry?
In conclusion, both the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 are excellent revolvers that offer exceptional performance and reliability. The S&W 686 is known for its sleek design, superior accuracy, and smooth action. It is a top choice for those who prioritize precision shooting.
On the other hand, the Ruger GP100 is known for its rugged design, durability, and overall value. It is a popular choice among those who require a reliable and robust revolver for self-defense purposes.
Ultimately, the choice between the S&W 686 and Ruger GP100 comes down to personal preference and intended use. Both revolvers have their strengths and weaknesses, and it is important to consider your specific needs and preferences before making a decision.
